Syed Balkhi

Entrepreneur. Investor. Marketing Extraordinaire.

  • Home
  • About
  • My Companies
  • Blog
  • Contact

October 8, 2014

Alexa is Bullshit – Please Stop Using it as a Traffic Comparison Tool

Alexa is Bullshit
Share:
Share
Tweet
Share
0 Shares

Alexa is Bullshit, and we need to stop using it as a traffic comparison tool.

I thought this was common knowledge, but even now I have seen speakers boasting about their site’s Alexa rank.

What’s worst is when consultants start telling business owners that their website needs to be in the top 100k alexa rank for it to be legitimate.

I was at an event when another speaker approached me to give compliments about WPBeginner’s Alexa rank which is 1317 at the time of writing this article. After the compliment, he started bragging about his own site which is in the top 50k.

Well before you make yourself look like a fool, let me tell you why Alexa is mostly bogus, and you should probably stop using it as a traffic comparison tool.

Alexa attempts to rank top websites in the world which if you look at their top 10, I probably wouldn’t even debate about. Sure Google, Facebook, YouTube, etc are the most visited sites on the planet.

However as you start going down the list, it doesn’t add up. Let me explain.

I run several websites that are in the top 50,000 alexa. However for the sake of this article, we will only analyze the following:

  • WPBeginner.com (Alexa rank 1317)
  • List25.com (Alexa rank 13,333)
  • OptinMonster.com (Alexa rank 13,175)

As you can see, all three of those are in the top 15,000 websites in the world according to Alexa. However the order they’re ranked in is completely wrong.

It wouldn’t take a genius to figure out that the most popular website among the three is List25. I mean come on, just look at the YouTube channel as an indicator (roughly 1.3 million subscribers and 203 million video views).

The site itself gets a crap load of visitors compared to WPBeginner and OptinMonster. Because I have Google Analytics, I can see more accurate data for each site.

Alexa is showing that OptinMonster is more popular than List25. Seriously?

List25 gets 6000% more traffic than OptinMonster site.

List25 gets a significant amount more traffic than WPBeginner as well because of it’s mass appeal compared to WPBeginner which has a smaller target audience.

Even though Alexa states the numbers are estimated, you can clearly see that the estimates are way off the mark.

I will end this rant with a small request, please stop using Alexa as a traffic comparison tool and save your dignity.

Category:Business

Syed Balkhi

Syed Balkhi

I am an award-winning young entrepreneur with strong 8-figure online businesses. I was recognized as the top 100 entrepreneur under the age of 30 by the United Nations. Our software runs on over 9 million websites serving billions of impressions every month.
More About Me

Ultimate Toolkit for Growing Your Online Business

Sign up to download Syed's free Growth Toolkit and receive exclusive business advice.

Exclusive Business Advice My Tool Box for Success Super Secret Bonus
Get Exclusive Content (FREE)

You might also like...

  • Selling a WordPress Business

    July 3, 2018

    5 Lessons from Selling a Multi-Million Dollar WordPress Plugin Business

    September 1, 2016

    4 Benefits of Company Retreats + 3 Planning Lessons that I Learned

    Affiliate Program

    August 5, 2016

    Setting up Your Own Affiliate Program? Don’t Make This Mistake!

  • WordPress.com vs WordPress.org - Which is Better? (Comparison)
    5 Best Contact Form Plugins for WordPress Compared
    Best WooCommerce Hosting (Reviews & Performance Tests)
    How to Create an Email Newsletter the RIGHT WAY (Step by Step)
    How to Create a Free Business Email Address in 5 Minutes (Step by Step)
    Why is WordPress Free? What are the Costs? What is the Catch?
    How Much Does It Really Cost to Build a WordPress Website?
    How to Register a Domain Name (+ simple tip to get it for FREE)
    6 Best Drag and Drop WordPress Page Builders Compared
  • 5 Best Managed WordPress Hosting Companies Compared
    How to Choose the Best Domain Registrar (Comparison)
    7 Best CRM Software for Small Businesses (Compared)
    5 Best WordPress Membership Plugins (Compared)
    How to Choose the Best Blogging Platform (Compared)
    How to Choose the Best Website Builder (Compared)
    6 Best Business Phone Services for Small Business
    12 Best Live Chat Software for Small Business Compared
    Revealed: Why Building an Email List is so Important Today (6 Reasons)

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. AvatarGlenn Dixon

    October 19, 2019

    Yes, THIS! Thanks for writing this Syed. Even though I knew it was bogus, it’s nice to have a metric I can point to for validation.

    Reply
    • Syed BalkhiSyed Balkhi

      October 19, 2019

      Happy to help :)

      Reply
  2. AvatarLance Cleveland

    October 19, 2019

    What tools do you suggest for comparing site popularity even if it is specific to certain vertical markets? When pitching a business or website for sale the buyer inevitably wants to know ”how do you compare to x”. X is usually not public about their GA numbers.

    Reply
    • Syed BalkhiSyed Balkhi

      October 19, 2019

      That’s a really hard task. I wish there was a magic tool, but it doesn’t exist. If the site has verified Quantcast data, then that’s pretty close. However if they don’t, then you have to make your best educated guess based on the social media engagement, following, etc.

      Reply
  3. Avatarchevypowell

    October 19, 2019

    Syed Balkhi While Alexa is only based on the amount of traffic recorded from users that have the Alexa toolbar installed over a period of three months. I found it reasonable where the list is concerned . WPbeginner targets wordpress users and web designer etc, these people are more likely to install the tool bar rather than list25.com , where the audience is scattered . Same goes with OptinMonster.com

    Reply
    • Syed BalkhiSyed Balkhi

      October 19, 2019

      I’m very familiar with how Alexa ranks the sites which is why I say it’s a flawed system and should never be used as a traffic comparison tool.

      Reply
    • AvatarPam Blizzard

      October 19, 2019

      I disagree that WP designers are more likely to install the bloated Alexa tool bar. We tend to know better.

      Reply
  4. AvatarFMCG The Power of FMCG

    October 19, 2019

    Take a retrospective view on one of leading companies’ marketing efforts at “FMCG: The Future of Fast Moving Consumer Goods”.

    ‘A Mars a Day Helps You Work, Rest and Play’ – Mars’ 1959 successful campaign

    Check fmcgbook.com for more details.

    Reply
  5. AvatarJohn R. Meese

    October 19, 2019

    I knew Alexa was a rough estimate, but I had no idea it was so far off the mark! Thanks for the heads up, Syed.

    Reply
  6. AvatarAadil Shah

    October 19, 2019

    I still think Alexa is a good indicator how a site is doing generally but I do agree it is not completely accurate. I tried their free trial to check my site ranking and compare it, but was severely disappointed.

    Reply
  7. AvatarKundan Bhardwaj

    October 19, 2019

    Man, its like you pulled out my words. I would totally agree with the fact about Alexa’s accuracy and way to rank websites is buggy. I understand that it only counts visitors passed through its toolbar or widgets, one of the reasons webmasters add alexa widgets on their blogs. Lol , I do it aswell.

    Reply
  8. AvatarGursimran Singh Reehal

    October 19, 2019

    Don’t worry, anyone who’s serious about researching site statistics nowadays is more than aware about Alexa’s reputation. Would love to hear what your views are on Compete and Quantcast’s traffic rankings in context to your websites.

    BTW, WpBeginner brought me here. Great work.

    Reply
  9. AvatarGary Adams

    October 19, 2019

    Glad I found this article because I agree with you I get a ton of traffic and my rank was going to a certain point then going back to were it originally started I was like wtf is this crapola. why should I keep paying $50 a month for most inaccurate readings ever seen. I agree with you thanks Syed.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Footer

Connect With Me:

Site Links

  • About
  • Blog
  • My Companies
  • Contact
  • Careers

Learn WordPress

  • WPBeginner
  • Start a Blog
  • Make a Website
  • Start an Online Store
  • Email Marketing
  • Best WordPress Plugins

Sites I Like

  • Amanda Balkhi
  • Balkhi Foundation
  • Thomas Griffin
  • Nameboy
  • IsItWP
  • BlogTyrant

My Companies

  • OptinMonster
  • WPForms
  • MonsterInsights
  • RafflePress
  • SeedProd
  • TrustPulse

© 2019 Syed Balkhi. All Rights Reserved. WordPress Hosting by HostGator. CDN by MaxCDN.

Privacy Policy My Disclosure Policy Contact